Category Archives: .NET


.NET Stopwatch meet IDisposable

You’re probably aware of the .NET Stopwatch class, a System.Diagnostics class that ‘Provides a set of methods and properties that you can use to accurately measure elapsed time’.

A code sample illustrates its typical usage:

Stopwatch stopWatch = new Stopwatch();
// Get the elapsed time as a TimeSpan value.
TimeSpan ts = stopWatch.Elapsed;

You get the idea – create, start, execute code (thanks Thread.Sleep(…)), stop and examine its Elapsed property.

There are a number of open source profilers such as Prof-It that provide comprehensive timing information, and there can be some discrepancies when timing code execution with a Stopwatch, as this excellent Code Project article explains, it’s often sufficient to temporarily put in a Stopwatch block to time a piece of code.

One thing to note from the code sample is that it is a little verbose.  The Thread.Sleep(…) call is trivial, for our example, but if we’re timing several lines, the various Stopwatch boilerplate lines rather get in the way.

Wouldn’t it be nice if we could write something like this:

using (new CleverTimer()))

We can, with this little ‘CleverTimer’ class, which uses a mix of a Stopwatch and IDisposable:

public class CleverTimer : IDisposable
	private readonly Stopwatch _stopwatch;
	private readonly Action<Stopwatch> _action;
	public CleverTimer(Action<Stopwatch> action = null)
		_action = action ?? (s => Console.WriteLine(s.ElapsedMilliseconds));
		_stopwatch = new Stopwatch();
	public void Dispose()
	public Stopwatch Watch
		get { return _stopwatch; }

The class has a couple of members – the all important Stopwatch, as well as an Action of type Stopwatch.  The constructor can accept an Action, but defaults to writing out the Elapsed milliseconds of the stopwatch.   The constructor creates a the member Stopwatch and starts it.

The Dispose method, required for the implementation of the IDisposable interface, simple stops the Stopwatch member and invokes the _action code.

It’s all fairly simple stuff, but goes some way to simplifying timed code.

Book Review – Instant .NET 4.5 Extension Methods How-to

Packt’s ‘Instant’ Series promises short, fast, focused guides delivering immediate results. But does their Instant .NET 4.5 Extension Method How-to incarnation deliver, or leave readers wanting more?

It is indeed a short book – 52 pages, and it’s 25% before the technical content starts.

.NET 4.5 Extension Methods How-to
.NET 4.5 Extension Methods How-to

After a brief general introduction, the book follows a code sample and explanation format. Each item is labelled with a difficulty grading, with ‘must know’, ‘should now’, and ‘become an expert’.

The ‘become an expert’ items go beyond the ‘syntactic sugar’ aspects of extension methods and demonstrate their usage in modern .NET design.

Whilst the book costs just over a fiver here in the UK, I felt that it was a little lacking. I spotted a grammatical and code formatting issue, and the format of code and explanation feels a little rushed. The more advanced areas would have ideally had more explanation as to how extension methods fit into the .NET ecosystem.

Another issue is that the book offers nothing over the wealth of articles freely available on the Internet.

Testing .NET Private Methods

If you’ve developed a .NET application, chances are you’ve used private methods in your design. Their inclusion brings about several advantages, but unit testing them isn’t immediately obvious. In fact, whether to unit test private methods at all is frequently debated, with opponents citing that they shouldn’t be considered because only a public interface is used in a real-world scenario.

I feel that private methods should be tested, because a core idea of unit testing is to test small units of functional code, which by definition, includes private methods.

Without question, private methods are trickier to unit test than public methods; at first glance, it isn’t obvious at all. Unit testing code is client code after all, and by definition, private methods aren’t visible. However, there are ways, and I present three of them here.

  1. Roll your own private method call using reflection
  2. Use the .NET InternalsVisibleTo attribute
  3. Use the test team API’s PrivateObject class